Tagged: fobossdr

TechMinds: RigExpert Responds to TechMinds’ Review of the FobosSDR

In a previous video released last week, Matt from the TechMinds YouTube channel reviewed the RigExpert FobosSDR. The FobosSDR is an RX-only USB 3.0 device, with a 100 kHz to 6 GHz tuning range, 50 MHz of bandwidth, and 14-bit ADC resolution. It comes in at a price reasonable for its specs, which is US$395 from US resellers and from EU resellers around 495,00 €.

However, while the specs look good on paper, Matt's previous review exposed some severe imaging problems with the device, and noted that lower cost SDRs with similar specs performed much better. Imaging is when strong out of band signals overlap onto other bands, causing issues with receiving signals. This is usually a symptom of incorrect code, poorly thought out design, or poor filtering in hardware.

In the latest video Matt goes through RigExpert's reply to his video review. In the video the reply from RigExpert stresses that only certain sample rates chosen by the user will result in correct performance in terms of imaging. When the correct sampling rate is chosen Matt observes that the imaging is resolved on the HF bands, although it does not help with the broadcast FM band imaging onto the airband in VHF.

RigExpert also stresses that the FobosSDR is not designed to be a high performance HF SDR and that it is designed to excel in the 50 MHz to 6 GHz range only. However, Matt points out that their marketing goes against this statement, as it advertises that FobosSDR has applications in "high performance HF" and "HAM radio".

They also note that the official software for FobosSDR is uSDR, and this should be used for best performance. But in his tests, Matt notes that the uSDR software has poor audio quality and FFT resolution on the waterfall, with no settings found to improve it.

Overall, many of the problems seem to stem from a disconnect between the marketing, documentation, and technical people working on the FobosSDR. It also seems that some of the issues could have been solved with additional or tighter built-in filters. But with the retail cost already in the upper range of this spec bracket, they may have opted for the cheaper option which is to tell users to use external filters if necessary. 

RigExpert Responded To My Fobos SDR Review Video!

TechMinds: A Review of the RigExpert FobosSDR

Earlier this year the Ukrainian company RigExpert released the FobosSDR, and only recently has it become available to most people in the world via global resellers. FobosSDR is an RX-only USB 3.0 device, with a 100 kHz to 6 GHz tuning range, 50 MHz of bandwidth, and 14-bit ADC resolution. Current pricing from US resellers is US$395 and from EU resellers around 495,00 €.

Recently Matt from the TechMinds YouTube channel reviewed the FobosSDR, showing an unboxing, description and review of the hardware. Unfortunately, while the specs on paper look good, Matt notes that the FobosSDR does not perform well.

In the video, Matt starts by testing around the broadcast FM band and shows how the FobosSDR suffers from multiple mirrored signals, even with the gain settings turned right down. He notes that other similarly priced SDRs perform a lot better and that even an RTL-SDR performs better.

Matt then goes on to test the HF bands, noting that there is no gain control available on these bands and that there are also extreme levels of signal mirroring all across the HF band.

Unfortunately, we are starting to see other similar reports about poor performance from the FobosSDR. For example, on arcticdx's blog he also does not recommend the SDR [1][2],

RigExpert Fobos SDR 100KHz To 6GHz SDR Receiver

A Video Review of FobosSDR

Back in April of this year, we posted about the FobosSDR, an upcoming software defined radio product from the Ukrainian company RigExpert. FobosSDR is an RX-only USB 3.0 device, with a 100 kHz to 6 GHz tuning range, 50 MHz of bandwidth, and 14-bit ADC resolution. At the time of the previous post, FobosSDR was not yet for sale, but now we see that it is available from some European distributors with a price of 495,00 € (~US$544).

Recently 'Radio Bunker' has uploaded a video review of the FobosSDR on his YouTube channel. Note that the video is in Spanish, however, you can use the YouTube auto-translate function.

In the video, Radio Bunker unboxes the FobosSDR and explains its specs and features, then goes on to show how to install the drivers and get it up and running with SDR#. He then shows the SDR receiving some signals like broadcast AM, FM, shortwave, DAB, and WiFi in SDR# with 50 MHz bandwidth.

▶️ REVIEW: FOBOS SDR ◀️ UN RECEPTOR SDR DE GAMA ALTA

uSDR Software Updated to V1.7.0

Thank you to Viol for writing in and letting us know that his uSDR software has recently been updated to V1.7.0. The uSDR software (not to be confused with the unrelated uSDR hardware) is a lightweight general-purpose multimode program for Windows that supports the RTL-SDR, Airspy, BladeRF, HackRF, LimeSDR, and other SDR radios.

Viol highlights the latest features added in the 1.7.0 update below:

  • Fobos SDR frontend native support, the very new SDR from RigExpert
  • bladeRF API v2.5.0 support, oversampling mode up to 122.88 MHz sample rate (do not forget to update FX3 firmware)
  • advanced IQ playback mode, precise timing and streaming
  • improved DSP routines and memory management, minimized CPU load
  • excellent ruler tool for spectrum frequency and amplitude measurements
uSDR Updated to Version 1.7.0. Images shows FobosSDR support.
uSDR Updated to Version 1.7.0. Images shows FobosSDR support.

FobosSDR: A New SDR Receiver with 100 kHz to 6 GHz Tuning Range and 50 MHz Bandwidth for $395

Recently we've seen that a new SDR from the Ukrainian company RigExpert has been released. The RX-only USB3.0 SDR is called 'FobosSDR' and it has a 100 kHz to 6 GHz tuning range, 50 MHz of bandwidth, and 14-bit resolution. Apart from a standard RF input, it also has two auxiliary input channels for coherent direct sampling and clock in and out ports.

In terms of software support, the FobosSDR supports HDSDR, and interestingly a very old version of SDR# (SDR# 1716) through a plugin. They also have a GNU Radio block.

The design is based on the LTC2143 ADC and uses a wideband RFFC5072 mixer on the front end which feeds into a MAX2830 transceiver chip.

RigExpert products are carried by a number of resellers across the world, but FobosSDR does not yet appear to be available from any that we checked. So far we have not seen any reviews or demonstrations of the product in action, but will update if we do.

FobosSDR